Alaway vs Pataday: Best Allergy Eye Drops Compared

What Are Alaway and Pataday?

Alaway and Pataday are both anti-allergy eye drops designed to relieve itchy eyes caused by allergens like pollen, pet dander, and dust mites. These over-the-counter (OTC) antihistamine eye drops work by blocking histamine, the chemical responsible for triggering allergic reactions in your eyes.

Alaway

Alaway contains ketotifen fumarate as its active ingredient. This antihistamine eye drop is available OTC and provides up to 12 hours of relief from itchy eyes. Alaway is approved for adults and children ages 3 and older.

The drops work quickly, typically providing relief within minutes of application. Many users appreciate Alaway's affordability compared to other allergy eye drops for contacts and prescription alternatives.

Pataday

Pataday contains olopatadine hydrochloride and comes in multiple formulations. The original Pataday Once Daily Relief provides 16 hours of protection, while Pataday Extra Strength offers 24-hour relief with just one drop per day.

Previously available only by prescription, Pataday is now sold OTC. It's approved for adults and children ages 2 and older, making it suitable for younger patients than Alaway.

What Is the Difference Between Alaway and Pataday?

The main difference between Alaway and Pataday is their active ingredients and duration of relief. Alaway uses ketotifen fumarate and lasts up to 12 hours, while Pataday contains olopatadine hydrochloride and provides 16 to 24 hours of protection depending on the formulation you choose.

Here are the key differences between these two allergy eye drops:

• Active ingredient: Alaway contains ketotifen fumarate; Pataday contains olopatadine hydrochloride
• Duration of relief: Alaway provides 12 hours; Pataday offers 16-24 hours
• Age approval: Alaway is approved for ages 3+; Pataday is approved for ages 2+
• Dosing frequency: Alaway requires twice-daily dosing; Pataday Extra Strength needs only once daily

Unlike other eye drops like Visine, both Alaway and Pataday are antihistamines specifically designed for allergic reactions rather than general redness relief. This makes them more effective for treating hay fever symptoms affecting the eyes.

How Do Alaway and Pataday Work?

Alaway and Pataday work by blocking histamine, the chemical your body releases during an allergic reaction that causes itching, redness, and watering. Both medications are antihistamine eye drops that prevent histamine from binding to receptors in your eyes, providing relief from uncomfortable allergy symptoms.

Alaway's Mechanism

Alaway's active ingredient, ketotifen fumarate, acts as both an antihistamine and a mast cell stabilizer. This dual action not only blocks histamine but also prevents mast cells from releasing additional histamine. The result is effective relief from sneezing and other allergy symptoms affecting your eyes for up to 12 hours.

Pataday's Mechanism

Pataday uses olopatadine hydrochloride, which similarly functions as an antihistamine and mast cell stabilizer. Its formulation allows for longer-lasting protection, with Pataday Extra Strength providing up to 24 hours of relief. Unlike combination drops like Opcon-A, Pataday doesn't contain decongestants, making it gentler for daily use.

What Are the Side Effects of Alaway vs Pataday?

The side effects of Alaway and Pataday are generally mild and similar, including temporary burning, stinging, dry eyes, and headaches. Both medications are well-tolerated by most users, though individual reactions may vary. Serious side effects are rare but should prompt immediate medical attention if they occur.

Alaway Side Effects

Common side effects of Alaway (ketotifen fumarate) include:

• Mild burning or stinging upon application
• Dry eyes
• Eye redness or irritation
• Headache
• Runny nose

These effects typically subside within minutes of application. If you experience severe eye pain, vision changes, or signs of an allergic reaction, discontinue use and consult your doctor immediately.

Pataday Side Effects

Pataday (olopatadine hydrochloride) shares similar side effects with Alaway:

• Temporary burning or stinging sensation
• Blurred vision
• Dry eyes
• Unusual taste in mouth
• Headache

Most users find Pataday comfortable for daily allergy prevention. Contact your healthcare provider if side effects persist or worsen over time.

How Often Should You Use Alaway vs Pataday?

Alaway requires twice-daily dosing, while Pataday offers once-daily convenience depending on the formulation. Alaway (ketotifen fumarate) should be applied every 8-12 hours for optimal relief. Pataday Once Daily Relief (olopatadine hydrochloride 0.2%) needs just one application, while Pataday Twice Daily Relief requires two doses daily.

Alaway Dosing Guidelines

Apply one drop of Alaway in each affected eye every 8-12 hours. This twice-daily schedule maintains consistent antihistamine levels throughout the day. For best results, use the drops at the same times each day, such as morning and evening.

Pataday Dosing Guidelines

Pataday Once Daily Relief provides 24-hour protection with a single morning application. This makes it ideal for those who prefer minimal daily maintenance. Pataday Twice Daily Relief follows a similar schedule to Alaway, requiring applications approximately 6-8 hours apart for continuous symptom control.

Which Is Better for Allergies: Alaway or Pataday?

Neither Alaway nor Pataday is universally better—the best choice depends on your specific needs and lifestyle. Both effectively relieve itchy, watery eyes caused by allergies. Pataday offers once-daily convenience, while Alaway tends to be more affordable. Your decision should factor in dosing preferences, age requirements, and contact lens use.

Best for Contact Lens Wearers

Contact lens wearers should remove their lenses before applying either eye drop. With Alaway, you must wait at least 10 minutes before reinserting contacts. Pataday requires a similar waiting period. Both products contain preservatives that can be absorbed by soft contact lenses, potentially causing irritation or discoloration over time.

Best for Children

Alaway is approved for children ages 3 and older, while Pataday Once Daily Relief is approved for ages 2 and up. This makes Pataday a slightly better option for younger children needing allergy eye relief. Parents often prefer Pataday's once-daily dosing since it simplifies the treatment routine for kids who may resist eye drops. For children with multiple allergies, allergy drops offer a needle-free treatment option that addresses the root cause rather than just symptoms.

Can You Use Alaway and Pataday Together?

Using Alaway and Pataday together is generally not recommended since both medications treat the same symptoms through similar mechanisms. Combining them won't provide additional relief and may increase your risk of side effects. If one product isn't providing adequate relief, consult your doctor about alternative treatments rather than doubling up.

Both eye drops work as antihistamines, so using them simultaneously offers no therapeutic advantage. If you're experiencing persistent eye allergy symptoms despite using either medication correctly, consider these options:

• Talk to your doctor about prescription-strength alternatives
• Explore sublingual immunotherapy drops that address the underlying cause of allergies
• Add artificial tears between doses to help flush allergens from your eyes

How Much Do Alaway and Pataday Cost?

OTC and vary in price depending on the retailer and bottle size. Alaway typically costs between $10 and $15 for a 10mL bottle, while Pataday ranges from $15 to $25 for a similar size, making Alaway the more budget-friendly option.

Several factors can influence the final price you pay:

• Store brand alternatives may offer similar active ingredients at lower costs
• Larger bottle sizes often provide better value per milliliter
• Pharmacy rewards programs and manufacturer coupons can reduce expenses
• Generic versions of ketotifen (Alaway's active ingredient) are widely available

Pataday's higher price point reflects its once-daily dosing convenience and longer-lasting formula. If cost is a significant concern and you don't mind applying drops twice daily, Alaway offers effective relief at a lower price.

What Are Other Treatment Options for Eye Allergies?

Beyond eye drops like Alaway and Pataday, several other treatment options can help manage eye allergies effectively. These include oral antihistamines, cold compresses, artificial tears, and immunotherapy. While eye drops provide targeted relief, combining treatments often yields the best results for persistent symptoms.

Other OTC options that may complement your eye allergy treatment include:

• Oral antihistamines like cetirizine or loratadine to reduce overall allergic response
• Artificial tears to flush allergens from the eyes and provide moisture
• Cold compresses to soothe itchy, swollen eyes
• Decongestant eye drops for short-term redness relief

Sublingual Immunotherapy

Sublingual immunotherapy offers a long-term solution for eye allergies by addressing the root cause rather than just masking symptoms. This treatment involves placing allergy drops or tablets under the tongue daily to gradually desensitize your immune system to specific allergens.

Unlike eye drops that require ongoing use, sublingual immunotherapy can provide lasting relief even after treatment ends. Many patients experience significant improvement in their eye allergy symptoms within the first few months of treatment. This approach is particularly beneficial for those who find daily eye drop application inconvenient or insufficient for controlling their symptoms.

Live Allergy-Free with Wyndly

If you want long-term relief from your allergies, Wyndly can help. Our doctors will help you identify your allergy triggers and create a personalized treatment plan to get you the lifelong relief you deserve. Start by taking our quick online allergy assessment today!

Frequently Asked Questions

Which allergy eye drop is best?

The best allergy eye drop depends on your symptoms. Antihistamine drops like ketotifen (Zaditor) work well for itching. Olopatadine (Patanol, Pataday) combines antihistamine and mast cell stabilizer effects. For severe symptoms, prescription options like Lastacaft may help. Consult your doctor to determine which option suits your specific needs.

Is Pataday extra strength safe during pregnancy?

Pataday Extra Strength (olopatadine) has not been adequately studied in pregnant women. While animal studies haven't shown harm, you should consult your doctor before using it during pregnancy. Your healthcare provider can weigh the potential benefits against possible risks and recommend safer alternatives if needed.

What is the strongest allergy eye drops?

Prescription eye drops containing corticosteroids like loteprednol or fluorometholone are typically the strongest options for severe allergic eye symptoms. For over-the-counter choices, antihistamine drops with ketotifen or olopatadine provide effective relief. Always consult an allergist or eye doctor to determine the best option for your specific condition.

What is the difference between Pataday and Alaway?

Pataday and Alaway are both antihistamine eye drops for allergic conjunctivitis. Pataday contains olopatadine and is available in once-daily and twice-daily formulations. Alaway contains ketotifen and is typically used twice daily. Pataday was previously prescription-only but is now available over-the-counter like Alaway.

What are the side effects of Alaway?

Common side effects of Alaway (ketotifen) eye drops include temporary burning or stinging upon application, dry eyes, eye redness, headache, and runny nose. Less common side effects may include eye pain, blurred vision, and eyelid swelling. Serious allergic reactions are rare but require immediate medical attention.